ILIAD 2

Compare and contrast the battle scene between Hector and the Great Ajax in the movie TROY from their real battle according to Homer.

The battle scene between Hector and the Great Ajax in the movie TROY:

The real battle between Hector and the Great Ajax:

Hector and Ajax begin their duel by tossing spears. They then use their lances, and Ajax draws Hector’s blood. They are about to clash with swords when heralds, spurred by Zeus, call off the fight on account of nightfall. They exchange gifts and end their duel with a pact of friendship.

Reference:http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/iliad/section5.rhtml

The battle scene between Hector and the Great Ajax in the movie troy is brutal and full of anger while in the real battle between Hector and the Great Ajax is fair with a pact of friendship. In the movie troy Hector won the fight against the Great Ajax by stabbing his sword to Ajax's stomach while in the real battle between the two was spurred by Zeus and they exchange gift and end their duel. Both in the movie and in the book Hector and Great Ajax gave their best and were determined to win the duel. And Hector and Great Ajax are both brave, wise, strong and great warrior.

If I were Homer, I would disagree the movie version of the fight between the two because it is too brutal and full of anger unlike in the book the real battle of the two was spurred by Zeus and end their duel with a pact of friendship. In my opinion being your friend is better than being your enemy. And if I were Homer, I would disagree because I would rather see peace than war.

ILIAD

Who is the nobler/greater/honorable man between Paris and Menelaus?

I think that Menelaus is nobler, greater & honorable man than Paris because in the story "Paris, the Trojan prince who precipitated the war by stealing the beautiful Helen from her husband, Menelaus, challenges the Achaeans to single combat with any of their warriors. When Menelaus steps forward, however, Paris loses heart and shrinks back into the Trojan ranks. Hector, Paris’s brother and the leader of the Trojan forces, chastises Paris for his cowardice. Stung by Hector’s insult, Paris finally agrees to a duel with Menelaus, declaring that the contest will establish peace between Trojans and Achaeans by deciding once and for all which man shall have Helen as his wife. Hector presents the terms to Menelaus, who accepts. Both armies look forward to ending the war at last.

As Paris and Menelaus prepare for combat, the goddess Iris, disguised as Hector’s sister Laodice, visits Helen in Priam’s palace. Iris urges Helen to go to the city gates and witness the battle about to be fought over her. Helen finds the city’s elders, including Priam, gathered there. Priam asks Helen about the strapping young Achaeans he sees, and she identifies Agamemnon, Ajax, and Odysseus. Priam marvels at their strength and splendor but eventually leaves the scene, unable to bear watching Paris fight to the death.

Paris and Menelaus arm themselves and begin their duel. Neither is able to fell the other with his spear. Menelaus breaks his sword over Paris’s helmet. He then grabs Paris by the helmet and begins dragging him through the dirt, but Aphrodite, an ally of the Trojans, snaps the strap of the helmet so that it breaks off in Menelaus’s hands. Frustrated, Menelaus retrieves his spear and is about to drive it home into Paris when Aphrodite whisks Paris away to his room in Priam’s palace. She summons Helen there too. Helen, after upbraiding Paris for his cowardice, lies down in bed with him. Back on the battlefield, both the Trojans and the Greeks search for Paris, who seems to have magically disappeared. Agamemnon insists that Menelaus has won the duel, and he demands Helen back."

Reference:"http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/iliad/section3.rhtml"

Today many people are similar characteristics to Paris and Menelaus. Many people cheat and steal other person, they don't care on other person's feeling because they just think only for themselves like Paris. Meanwhile, many people are fighting for their love ones and for their dignity like Menelaus who fight for his wife. My opinion is that Menelaus is nobler, greater & honorable man than Paris because he don'd cheat and steal but he fights for his love ones and for his dignity unlike Paris.